Total votes contributed: 578452

Which place looks more upper-class?
The Project
The Process
Imagine traveling through a strange city...
Inside your mind, subconscious judgements about your surroundings are made in real time. Do you feel safe? Does the area you are in seem unique? Does it appear wealthy, clean or even energetic? You may not think about, let alone understand, what goes into making these anecdotal determinations, but when elicited, your opinions can be understood as part of a more substantial collective and used in powerful ways.
In 1960, Kevin Lynch published "The Image of the City" and established how people perceive and create mental models of the cities they inhabit. Since then, the fields of both architecture and urban planning have heavily studied urban perception, placing emphasis on everything from the macro scale of a city to the intricate details of an individual building. Institutional limitations, however, have limited the throughput of urban perception studies by constraining the quantity of both images and subjects used.
To mitigate these past limitations, we present Place Pulse. Place Pulse is a website that allows anybody to quickly run a perception study and visualize the results in powerful ways. Developed at the MIT Media Lab by the Macro Connections group, Place Pulse crowdsources surveys to internet participants, asking binary perception questions across a large number of geotagged images. From the responses of each participant, directed graphs are generated, which are then layered with the graphs of others, forming what we call a perception network. This perception network can be analyzed and visualized in a multitude of ways, allowing the experimenter to identify interesting patterns in the data, possibly forming the basis for a future hypothesis.
This is all made possible by manipulating readily available data on the internet and by employing massively scalable web technologies to aid in data collection and computation. Data collection is empowered by a community of participants who act as both survey creators and takers, while computation of this data relies on machine learning algorithms to identify which features contribute to held perceptions. With an increased understanding of perception from a more broad societal point of view, it may be possible for targeted changes, such as cleaning building facades and removing trash, but deciding to leave graffiti as-is, to have a disproportionate impact on the opinions of inhabitants and visitors alike.

For a question, such as "Which place looks safer?" users are asked to decide between pairs of images. As each image is compared, a ranking of which image is more, or less safe emerges. In the figure above, each line represents one time when those images were paired together and the arrows point from the winner to the loser. This process allows difficult, qualitative questions, such as "What place in New York City seems the safest to tourists?" to be broken down into simpler, binary decisions.







